An in-depth comparison: Metal lawn edging vs plastic, wood & stone

Choosing the right lawn edging material is crucial for maintaining a well-defined and organised outdoor space. Among the various options available, metal, plastic, wood, and stone are popular choices. Each material comes with its own set of advantages and drawbacks.

In this in-depth comparison, we'll explore the characteristics of metal lawn edging and contrast them with plastic, wood, and stone alternatives to help you make an informed decision for your landscaping needs.

Metal Lawn Edging

Metal lawn edging, crafted from materials such as aluminium or steel, is a popular choice for homeowners seeking durability and a sleek, modern appearance. Recognised for its resistance to weather elements and ease of installation, metal edging has become a staple in landscaping projects.

Metal Edging Pros

1. Durability: Metal edging, typically made of aluminium or steel, is known for its longevity and resistance to weather elements.
2. Versatility: Metal edging provides a sleek and modern look that complements various landscape styles, from contemporary to traditional.
3. Ease of Installation: Most metal edging products are designed for easy installation, often featuring interlocking sections or spikes for secure placement.
4. Low Maintenance: Metal is resistant to decay, pests, and rot, requiring minimal maintenance over time.

Kinley Edging Recommendations

• Steel Edging: premium metal edging that requires minimal maintenance and is available in various thicknesses and heights for different applications.

• Aluminium Edging: flexible metal edging that is lightweight yet incredibly robust, suitable for various applications.

Plastic Lawn Edging

Plastic lawn edging stands out as a cost-effective and flexible solution for those looking to define their outdoor spaces. With its affordability, lightweight nature, and resistance to rust, plastic is often favoured for its ease of installation and adaptability to various landscape designs. Yet, its durability over time and perceived aesthetic limitations often overweigh the advantages as it’s not a long-term solution.

Plastic Edging Pros

1. Affordability: Plastic edging is often more budget-friendly than metal, making it a cost-effective option for many homeowners.
2. Flexibility: Plastic edging is flexible and can be easily shaped to fit curves and contours in your landscape design.
3. Lightweight: The lightweight nature of plastic makes it easy to transport and install, requiring minimal effort.
4. Resistance to Rust: Unlike metal, plastic is not prone to rust, making it suitable for areas with high moisture.

Plastic Edging Cons 

1. Durability: Plastic may degrade over time due to exposure to sunlight and extreme weather conditions, leading to a shorter lifespan compared to metal or stone.
2. Aesthetic Limitations: Some people find that plastic lacks the aesthetic appeal of other materials, especially in upscale or formal landscaping designs.

Wooden Lawn Edging

Wooden lawn edging introduces a touch of natural beauty to landscapes, offering a warm and customisable option. While its biodegradability and customisation capabilities are appealing, the susceptibility to decay and rot poses challenges in terms of maintenance.

Wooden Edging Pros

1. Natural Aesthetics: Wood provides a warm and natural look, blending well with garden environments.
2. Customisation: Wooden edging can be easily cut and shaped to fit specific design requirements.
3. Biodegradable: Unlike plastic and metal, wood is a biodegradable material, making it environmentally friendly.

Wooden Edging Cons

1. Decay and Rot: Wood is susceptible to decay and rot, especially when in contact with soil and moisture. Regular maintenance, such as sealing or treating, is necessary to prolong its lifespan.
2. Installation Challenges: Installing wooden edging may require more effort and skill, as it often involves securing the pieces together with stakes or screws.

Stone Lawn Edging

Stone lawn edging exudes a timeless elegance, providing a durable and low-maintenance solution for landscaping projects. With a classic appearance and resistance to weathering, stone is often chosen for its enduring aesthetic appeal. However, the weight of stone and potential installation difficulties may require professional assistance, and the initial cost investment can be higher compared to other materials.

Stone Edging Pros

1. Durability: Stone is a durable and long-lasting material that can withstand various weather conditions.
2. Natural Appearance: Stone provides a classic and timeless look, adding an elegant touch to landscaping.
3. Low Maintenance: Once installed, stone edging typically requires minimal maintenance.

Stone Edging Cons

1. Weight and Installation Difficulty: Stone is heavy, making it more challenging to transport and install. Professional installation may be required for larger projects.
2. Cost: Stone edging can be more expensive than other materials, both in terms of material and installation costs.

Metal Garden Edging Solutions from Kinley

As a leading UK designer, innovator, and manufacturer of steel and aluminium driveway edging, we’re always happy to help. For more information on our complete line of products, inspiration for your future project and technical resources, get in touch with our team of expert advisors today.